IFLANET home - International Federation of Library Associations and InstitutionsActivities and ServicesSearchContacts

Minutes of the Acquisition and Collection Development Standing Committee meetings held at the 2002 IFLA Conference in Glasgow

Standing Committee meetings.
First on Saturday, 17 August, 11.30-14.20
Second on Friday, 23 August, 8.00-10.00
These minutes cover both meetings.

1. Attendance and general introductions

First meeting:

Committee members attending were:
Tatiana Afanasieva (Russia), Trix Bakker (Netherlands), Nancy Davenport, chair (USA), Christina Friström (Sweden), Rosa Garcia Blanco (Spain), Christine Girard (France), Masaki Nasu (Japan), Ann Okerson (USA), Montserrat Olivan (Spain), Liv Rustviken (Norway), Lynn Sipe (USA), Irina Skorikova (Russia), Marie Joëlle Tarin (France), Pentti Vattulainen, secretary (Finland)

Apologies were received from John Byford (UK), Doina Farkas (USA), Rolf Griebel (Germany), Susan Nutter (USA), Alexei P Romanov (Russia), and Lee Sook Hyeun (Korea).

Observers were:
Farzaneh Shadanpour (National Library of Iran), Klaus Kempf (Bavarian State Library, Munich, Germany), Paul Vermouth (Harvard College Library, USA), Joyce P Ludmer (Getty Research Institute, USA), Jacqueline Dubois (Bibliothèque de l'Université de Paris3), Souleymane Diouf (Bibliothèque de l'Université Cheikh Anta Diop de Dakar, Senegal), Kianoush Bayati (Parlamentary Library of Iran, Teheran) and Key Cassell (New York Public Library).

Second meeting:

Committee members attending were:
Tatiana Afanasieva (Russia), Trix Bakker (Netherlands), Nancy Davenport, chair (USA), Christina Friström (Sweden), Rosa Garcia Blanco (Spain), Christine Girard (France), Masaki Nasu (Japan), Ann Okerson (USA), Montserrat Olivan (Spain), Liv Rustviken (Norway), Lynn Sipe (USA), Irina Skorikova (Russia), Lee Sook Hyeun (Korea), Marie Joëlle Tarin (France) and Pentti Vattulainen, secretary (Finland)

Members not able to be present at the second meeting were John Byford (UK) and Doina Farkas (USA), Rolf Griebel (Germany), Susan Nutter (USA) and Alexei P Romanov (Russia).

Observers were:
Klaus Kempf (Bavarian State Library, Munich, Germany), Paul Vermouth (Harvard College Library, USA), Joyce P Ludmer (Getty Research Institute, USA), Souleymane Diouf (Bibliothèque de l'Université Cheikh Anta Diop de Dakar, Senegal), Key Cassell (New York Public Library), Hildegard Schaffer (Bavarian State Library, Munich), Pat Roberts (Jamaica Library Service), Marjory Sliney (Fingal County Libraries, Dublin Ireland), Lindile Nhlapo (Technicon South Africa), Tian Xiao Zhang (St.John's University, New York, USA), Aissa Issak (Mozambique), Bernard Dione (Senegal), Phegello Letsepa (National Library of South Africa).

2. Adoption of the Agenda

The agenda of the first meeting was approved as proposed. There was an addition to the agenda of the second meeting: Ann Okerson's report on Publishers Relations Advisory Committee.

3. Adoption of the Minutes from the Standing Committee meetings in Boston

The minutes of the Boston meeting were approved as written.

4. Acquisition and Collection Development events at the Glasgow Conference

    4.1. Open programme

    The Chair reported that the year had been a strange one. After the anthrax problems in Washington the Library of Congress could not receive mail until 4.3.2002. For example, all the finance papers did not arrive in time. As a result the Chair did not have much time and possibilities to work with the Section. The open programme - with the title "Collection Development Aspects of Life-long Learning" - had been allocated to the Chair and Susan Nutter. Susan Nutter had also problems in participating with planning the programme. So the only solution was to get another theme. Fortunately Robert Wedgeworth agreed to give a paper on literacy in the open session.

    In the second meeting there was feedback that the open programme on literacy had been interesting even though it was not closely connected with the section's scope.

    4.2. Workshop

    Ann Okerson presented the theme of the workshop "Evaluating and Measuring Electronic Resources". In electronic environment, a great deal of data about usage is available to librarians, who can begin to learn far more about the information needs of their readers and find better ways to meet those needs. But despite hard work on the part of librarians and information providers, electronic resources are rarely easy to gather, interpret, or compare. The workshop had the following outline:
    • Introduction and overview of the issues to evaluating and measuring electronic resources usage, Ann Okerson (Yale University, New Haven, USA)
    • Is it worth it? Unveiling what lies hidden in the E-resources statistics Kimberly Parker (Yale University Library, New Haven, USA)
    • User studies and what they teach us about electronic resources Kristiina Hormia-Poutanen (Helsinki University Library, Helsinki, Finland)
    • Defining success; electronic access for countries in transition Blazej Feret (Technical University of Lodz, Lodz, Poland
    • Developing an electronic library for scientific journals: a consortium project in Brazil Rosaly Favero Krzyzanowski (Electronic Lirbary Program/ Research Support -Foundation of the State of São Paulo, São Paulo, Brazil)

    The feedback from the standing committee was positive. The workshop was mentioned to have had very good structure: from local to regional and national level and finally describing challenges in a large international consortium. Speakers were good, all of them. Problems were connected with the hall which was too small (there were 90 attendants in a hall for 50 people) and which did not have slide projector.

    4.3. IFLA Booth

    IFLA Booth was scheduled for the section on Monday at 16.00-17.00. Nancy Davenport, Marie-Joëlle Tarin and Montserrat Oliván Plazaola volunteered to be present.

    Feedback was given in the second meeting: there were practically no delegates interested in specially the Section. IFLA Booth is obviously not a recruiting tool for the sections.

5. Report of other meetings

The Chair reported of the Coordinating Board meeting of the Division V Collection and Services. The delegates are supposed to wear their badges in the conference but not outside it. The CB hoped that all delegates would fill the evaluation form. In future conferences the open programmes will last two hours.

Ann Okerson reported on PRAC, Publishers Relations Advisory Committee in the second meeting. PRAC started 2 years ago to assist Ross Shimmon in discussions with the publishers. It has been chaired by Graham Cornish, who now has retired. Ann Okerson has started to convene the committee in June 2002. PRAC had its meeting was held on Monday 19th August. The committee discussed many matters including IFLA/IPA - statement, STM/IPA -paper on pricing, digital price management, matters connected with free literature for developing nations, content stability in electronic environment, alternative forms of publishing, standards for DOI (Digital Object Identifier) and how to adopt ICOLC licensing principles for IFLA.

6. Report of the Financial Officer

The Chair as the financial officer reported that the Check from Sara Yontan, the previous financial officer is in the anthrax backlog. So at the moment no financial report can be presented. It was agreed that the Chair sends the report by email to the members as soon as possible.

7. Activities of the Standing Committee

7.1. Projects

    7.1.1. Acquisitions Bibliography
    There was some discussion about the usefulness of the bibliography. The value was thought to be in the fact that it has entries in many other languages than in English, which seems to be the general language in many bibliographies. Ann Okerson proposed that the use a search engine would be clarified to make the use possible. The secretary would contact the IFLANET people on this.

    In the second meeting the discussion continued. IFLANET administers had informed that there is in principle a change of having a search engine for the bibliography. More information is still needed about the structure of the entries in the bibliography. It was decided to go on as before with the bibliography: members should provide 5 important references and abstracts of them in English.

    7.1.2. Handbook for the International Exchange of Publications
    The secretary presented the new plan for the handbook. It would contain of two parts: the directory and the "narrative" part. The staff of the Exchange Centre for Scientific Literature in Finland would update the directory after sending questionnaires to national exchange centres. The secretary would coordinate the writing of the narrative part. In the narrative part there would be text on international agreements, customs regulations, on the history of international exchanges, changes in the exchange of official publications and on the exchange of electronic publications. The final part would include examples of exchange activities in different countries and be based on the workshop held in Boston IFLA.

    The section discussed vividly on the topic from many points of view: the need for the handbook, effects of electronic publications on exchange, the role of exchanges in different types of libraries, special material types in exchange, on grey literature etc. Finally it was agreed to present the new plan to the Professional Coordinator Sjoerd Koopman, who would discuss about it with the publisher.

    In the second meeting the secretary reported that the professional coordinator had spoken to K.G. Saur, who had showed green light for the new plan

    7.1.3. Section Brochure
    The need for the new brochure was noted. Section members Liv Rustbacken and Lynn Sipe volunteered to revise the brochure. In the second meeting the standing committee added Christine Girard and Pentti Vattulainen to join the revision. Klaus Kempf volunteered to do the translation to Germany, Tatiana Afanasjeva to Russian and Montserrat Olivan to Spanish.

    7.1.4. Repository library conference
    The Center for Research Libraries announces that it plans to have the second International Conference on Repository Libraries if the funding can be arranged. Information on the conference will be announced in the autumn. If there will be a conference, the Section will co-sponsor it. Klaus Kempf and Pentti Vattulainen represent the section in preparations.

    The secretary will send information on the Center for Research Libraries to the members.

7.2. Publications

    7.2.1. Collection Policy Guidelines
    Rosa Garcia Blanco reported that the Spanish version of the Collection Policy Guidelines has been printed. It is also in the IFLANET.

    Russian colleagues announced that Russian version is being prepared.

    7.2.2. Newsletter
    Newsletter has been published twice: December 2001 and July 2002. It has been mailed to the members in paper form. It is also available electronically in IFLANET. It was agreed that the secretary sends e-mail to section members when the electronic version appears in IFLANET. The secretary had not yet got money to cover the costs of mailing.

8. Strategic plan

Was not discussed in this meeting.

9. Berlin IFLA 2003

The section plans three programmes to Berlin: a pre-conference, an open session and a workshop.

The pre-conference with the title "Digital Resources and Collection Development" will be held in Munich on 28.-31.7.2003. The local organiser is Bayerische Statsbibliothek. Local coordinator is Klaus Kempf. He introduced the theme and described excellent conference facilities and many possibilities for social events.

In the second meeting it was agreed that there would be a working group: Klaus Kempf, Ann Okerson and Pentti Vattulainen. Advisors from different continents would assist them. Following members and participants volunteered: Souleman Diop, Senegal, Trix Bakken, Holland, Masaki Nasu, Japan, Tatiana Afanasieva, Russia and Marie-Joëlle Tarin, France.

The section discussed on ideas for the open programme and the workshop. Several themes were mentioned:
- grey literature; electronic dissertations
- electronic legal deposit
- collection development policy
- gifts
- government documents and collection development
- licensing and the third world.

In the second meeting it was agreed that there would be an open programme on gifts co-ordinated by standing committee member Tatiana Afanasieva and Kay Cassell, New York Public Library. The workshop would be on co-operative collection development and organised by Pentti Vattulainen.

10. Buenos Aires 2004

Same themes were mentioned in discussions. It was agreed that it would be worth organising an event on licensing and the third world in Buenos Aires 2004.

11. Any other business

Standing committee dinner on Wednesday 23 August. The tradition was thought to be good and it was agreed to have the Section dinner also in Berlin. It was proposed to be on Friday 1st August.

SC member Masaki Nasu reported about the changes, such as an examination of the legal deposit system for online resources, in collection policy at the National Diet Library in Japan.

No other business.

*    

Latest Revision: December 30, 2002 Copyright ©
International Federation of Library Associations and Institutions
www.ifla.org