Fulfill the promise of the Innovation Union: European research institutions, libraries and archives need balanced copyright laws
[PDF webversion] [PDF all logos] [WORD]
Fulfill the promise of the Innovation Union:
European research institutions, libraries and archives need balanced copyright laws
Copyright exceptions and limitations for libraries and archives are currently being discussed by the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO) Standing Committee on Copyright & Related Rights (SCCR). The undersigned organisations feel they must express their deep disappointment following the European Union’s unwillingness to progress text-based discussions on this topic at the last meeting of the SCCR. In doing so, the European Union tried to reverse conclusions that had been previously agreed by all of the world’s countries at WIPO.
The undersigned European and international research institutions and library and archive organisations strongly urge the European Union and its Member States to ensure that text-based discussion of an international instrument on copyright exceptions and limitations for libraries and archives continues to be reflected in the mandate of the SCCR, and that the European Union engages constructively in these discussions. These discussions are important to:
1. Foster a cutting-edge, open international research culture
The European Union has identified international research and development collaboration as key to the success of the Innovation Union and the Europe 2020 initiative. Indeed, European countries are leading the world for international co-authorship.1 European research institutions need a research infrastructure that is globally oriented and supports seamless access to information across national borders,2 outside as well as within the EU.
The EU has also identified open access to research outputs as key for Europe as a means of supporting a more collaborative and open way to do science. Researchers are using new tools and methods to support research outputs, and copyright laws should facilitate, not stifle, this. The talks at WIPO potentially will enable the world’s libraries and archives to facilitate measured and reasonable access to their own cultural and scientific collections for the benefit of European citizens and researchers.
2. Ensure future researchers have access to our digitized and born-digital heritage
70% of total global journal publishing revenues are generated from academic library subscriptions.3 Despite libraries being the single biggest purchaser of scholarly publications, future researchers are in danger of being unable to access significant portions of our 20th and early 21st century digital heritage. Access to information in the digital environment is increasingly restricted by licensing and digital locks, which prevent libraries and archives from being able to preserve culture and research outputs for the future. National approaches to this problem fall short, because the digital information that researchers are accessing is now global.
3. Make European cultural heritage globally accessible
European libraries and archives possess rich collections that are important for the research and study of history and culture within Europe, and its historical influence on other cultures and societies. Today populations are mobile and multicultural. The internet holds the promise for libraries and archives to provide access to Europe’s collections globally, and to enable Europeans to access culturally important materials held by libraries and archives outside Europe, thereby enhancing global scholarship and learning.
The copyright challenges for libraries and archives
Copyright laws stop at the national border, both within the European Union and elsewhere, frustrating the efforts of libraries and archives whose mission is to ensure that people, regardless of their location and regardless of their means, have the potential to access Europe’s culture, history and scientific research. The European Union’s strong objection to text-based discussions of copyright exceptions and limitations at WIPO is particularly concerning in light of the Commission’s own ongoing consultations about updating Europe’s copyright laws, to better serve its Single Market.
The aspirations of the Internal Single Market are to support innovation, increase productivity, ensure the seamless flow of information and access to knowledge within EU borders, as well as encourage the creation of new copyright-protected works. Robust copyright exceptions and limitations are essential to this.
The international copyright framework is not working
The European Union has stated at SCCRs that the existing international copyright framework provides sufficient policy space for domestic copyright exceptions and limitations for libraries and archives [link]. Libraries, archives and research institutions at the most recent meeting of the SCCR provided ample illustrations of the challenges they face in the cross-border internet environment, where national exceptions are no longer enough [link]. In short:
- Under the existing treaties, copyright protections are mandatory while copyright exceptions are optional. This entrenched imbalance results in a patchwork approach to copyright exceptions in domestic copyright laws, with the public interest in education, scholarly research and innovation, and cultural preservation de-valued, in contrast with private interests.
- Increasingly, national copyright exceptions do not apply for libraries and archives. Licence terms set by publishers, often from other countries, override many exceptions in domestic copyright laws, and these terms can vary widely from licence to licence.
- This patchwork of national exceptions and the complexity of the licensing environment are frustrating international research collaboration, and placing libraries and archives in an ambiguous position as they try to lawfully fulfill their mission.
The undersigned organisations believe that a balanced and effective international copyright framework should support robust discussion of exceptions and limitations to copyright, as well as protections for creators. This can only be to everyone’s benefit. We ask the European Union to continue discussions of international copyright exceptions and limitations for libraries and archives at WIPO in good faith, and progress Committee work towards an international solution.
1As on 2012, France was ranked number 1 in the world for international co-authorship (50.0%), followed by the United Kingdom with 47.6%. Link
2A recent study identified 253 cross-border higher education programs (covering only branch campuses or franchising agreements) operating in the EU. Link (page 38).
3Ware, M, The STM Report: An Overview of scientific and scholarly journal publishing. Link (page 19).